Book Review: Tithe


Title: Tithe
 Holly Black
Genre: Young Adult, Fantasy, Urban Fantasy
Version: Paperback
Page Count: 331
Publisher: Simon Pulse
Synopsis: GoodReads
Notable Notables: POC Character, LGBTQ+ Character
Recommended Readers: Ages 14+, Lovers of Dark Themes
Rating: ★★★★☆


What a strange but enjoyable book this was. I borrowed Tithe from my roommate because I’ve been dying for a good Fae story, one where the Fae are all unbridled passions and cruel whims and outside the realms of human morality. Because that’s what Fae are supposed to be. I’ve heard Holly Black is dubbed by fans as the Faerie Queen, so I was hoping she wouldn’t disappoint me.

I’m happy to say that, by and large, she didn’t. She gave me the Seelie and Unseelie Courts in all their ethereal beauty, perverse horrors, and glorious madness. She gave me faeries that largely regard mortals as playthings to trick and lead to ruin.

The novel follows Kaye, a 16-year-old girl who keeps having to move from place to place because her mother fancies herself a rock star. After a sudden attack, Kaye returns to her childhood home in New Jersey and resumes contact with her faerie friends she once had as a child. She’s always been a weird kid, seeing things others couldn’t and imagining things into existence that shouldn’t be possible. When she stumbles upon an injured Fae knight, Roiben, and pulls an iron arrow from him, she becomes embroiled in a power struggle between the two Fae courts.

Tithe totes itself as “a modern faerie tale,” and it is. Much of it takes place in an urban city setting rather than just the lands of Faerie. Admittedly, the first third of the book threw me off specifically because of this urban setting. I have to confess, I don’t care much about reading anything about New Jersey nor about a bunch of 16-year-olds smoking, drinking, cussing at each other, and trying to be as edgy as possible. (Y’all are sixteen! Calm down, I’m laughing.) But once more faerie stuff starting happening, the easier it became to endure it.

Plus, I mean, Roiben was mighty fine. Yes, mighty fine, indeed. And the twist about Kaye I ended up liking so much more than I thought I would. It made their budding relationship all the more interesting for me, especially since it did lack some development in the beginning. Watching them work together throughout the story made up for that, though.

I also enjoyed Corny as a character, too, and was just as concerned about his journey as I was with Kaye’s. His “fling” with Nephamael was as terrible to watch as it was envious. (Hey, I love problematic ships, I can’t help it, and this was so inexplicably Fae, it scratched an itch that I needed scratched.) But that final scene with Corny and Nephamael was pure poetic justice, and I loved every second of it and Corny’s growth because of it.

I’m super excited to start the sequel. Not Valiant because I heard it doesn’t have much to do with this cast of characters, but Ironside. I want to see what other messes Kaye, Corny, and Roiben get into.

9 thoughts on “Book Review: Tithe

  1. I’m glad this worked out so well for you! I think I’m gonna suggest this as a read for my book club soon. Or just snag it for myself. Because I’m very interested in fae. *waggles eyebrows*


      • Yeah, it really depends on what direction this next book goes because I don’t want to be the reason we pile up on one genre and not explore multiple ones. I wanted to suggest ‘Autobiography of a Face’ by Lucy Grealy or ‘To the Lighthouse’ by Virginia Wolf, but we ended up deciding on one of Shannon’s choices. Some book called ‘The Winter Witch.’ I haven’t picked it up yet, I’m mostly just bummed that I couldn’t find an e-book copy of it last night from my library system for kindle. So I’m either going to be going there this weekend or trying to find it from my computer in the same form. So if ‘The Winter Witch’ ends up super fantasy, and not just “here’s some magic!” I may hold off on the suggestion until the round after.

        I can talk about it more with you, but SINCE I’M HERE~ Our first book club meeting went really well! I was happy to be there, and Chip made us a delicious cheese and meet plate and gave us wine. I suggest ‘Final Girls’ by Riley Sager to you because I’m mainly interested in what you might think of it. I’m getting deja vu writing that to you for some reason, but anyway. Lemme know if you pick it up… It’s like… 250 pages or something? Idk, it was a quick read, as well. And I have a LOT of thoughts, pre- and post-book club talk that I’d like to share with you on it.

        Okay I’m done. ❤

        Liked by 1 person

      • The Winter Witch… I don’t think I’ve heard of that one. Let me know how it goes! And ooh, yes, definitely adding Final Girls. It sounds dope AF.


    • You totally should! Gosh, I can’t believe it came out ten years ago! I’m late as usual, haha. Such a great Fae story, though. Have you read anything else by her?


      • You’re never too late to a good book! I just had to check my bookshelf to answer your question 😀. I’ve read Valiant and I’m sure I have read others but I can’t remember.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. You’re so right! And thanks for checking. I actually skipped Valiant because I heard it didn’t have much to do with the plot of the main characters introduced in Tithe. Was it good, if you remember? I started reading Holly Black because I heard about her book “The Cruel Prince” coming out in January that I’m really intrigued by. A friend got an ARC of it at NYCC, and she’s been raving about it, so now I’m suffering until then.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s